Nominees for Destructoid’s Best PC game of 2023

As we head into one of the last holiday weekends of the year, we’re wrapping up GOTY-related announcements with more nominees. This time, it’s for Destructoid’s best PC game of 2023, and I reckon you already know it’s a competitive bunch.

We’ve already hit the PlayStation and Xbox consoles, along with more specific categories like best indie and ongoing game. Looking back, I realize 2023 is one of the toughest years for GOTY choices I’ve had in ages, and I’m thankful this was a staff-wide endeavor; otherwise, this list would’ve taken until next year to shape up.

As always, our platform categories don’t mean the game only released on that platform. Plenty of the nominees here launched on both console and PC, but our formula still keeps games limited to one nomination in any given category. In the spirit of PC gaming, we approached this with more of a “Is this the preferred way to play?” — same with consoles. Anyway, here’s some really good games.

Starfield

Look, as far as I’m concerned, until we get mod support on Xbox then Starfield is a PC-only release. I’m joking (kind of), but Bethesda’s modding community is too damn good to ignore. But on that note, perhaps put the open-world RPG on your wishlist any way you can, as our swiss-army knife of a staff writer Steven Mills gave it the rare 10/10, making it one of Destructoid’s “essentials.”

In his review, Steven concluded:

“I wasn’t sure if it could be done, but Bethesda has managed to raise the bar for sandbox games even higher. In the end, Starfield is an epic sandbox open-world RPG with a beautifully immersive universe, a captivating story, and fun and compelling gameplay the whole way.”

Cocoon

Cocoon is among the year’s major visual delights. Even as someone who long grew tired of more puzzle-focused titles, Geometric Interactive demands attention with Cocoon’s bright pops of color and bizarre biomes. It’s got this smooth balance in its gradual incline to the more difficult mysteries, and even for those of us who don’t immediately rise to the challenge, it’s satisfying to poke around and fail.

Perhaps it’s no surprise, but the puzzler comes from the lead gameplay designer on Limbo and Inside Jeppe Carlsen. It’s not nearly as grim as the two of those, but there’s still a lot to the alien world that’s hauntingly mysterious and loaded with “aha!” moments of brilliance.

Slay the Princess

What a damn good year for indies, doubly so if you’re into cosmic horror and visual novels. Slay the Princess delivers on all fronts, with a premise and art style just as striking as its name. In hindsight, my image choice makes this look like a very nice, to-the-point, Princess Peach rescue-style situation. It’s not.

Usually, senior editor Eric Van Allen’s tastes line up well with my own, so his word was enough for the sale. In Eric’s review of Slay the Princess, he’s got plenty of praise to offer, and sums it up with:

“It’s about the interpersonal relationships that can wound us, make us versions of ourselves we never imagined, yet teach us. It is a damn good story, and one worth experiencing.”

Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty

I’ll say it right off the bat: I’m not in the camp of belief that you can’t count Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty as its own thing or even as something that was ongoing. Expansions, add-ons, DLC — whatever, there’s a whole valid debate there for next year on where we need to see new categories, but the RPG delivered on PC with more cleanup and intrigue in a “fitting swan song for Cyberpunk 2077.“

Our senior editor’s description fits, as CDPR’s RPG, for real this time, just launched its last big update on December 5 with the Ultimate Edition. Whatever becomes of the series’ future, Phantom Liberty was a good place to bookend our adventures in 2077’s Night City.

BattleBit Remastered

It’s always nice to find another gem playable on my ancient relic of a laptop. BattleBit Remastered low-poly massive FPS battleground is easy to pick up and put down for some satisfying chaos with friends or just 200-something strangers. It’s a nice change from some of its massively online genre cousins, and even in the chaos of having way too many people around you in a firefight, BattleBit plays keeps up just fine.

This was one of those games that hit big in the year and somehow missed until the very end, but the arsenal of vehicles, combat role focus, and destructible arena scratch an itch I’m not getting from the more mainstream. Bonus points here for keeping anti-cheat woes top of mind; when I get a new Steam Deck, it’ll (hopefully) join my very short list of multiplayer games where EAC didn’t rain on the portable experience.

Baldur’s Gate 3

If there were a “game with most characters Andrea would like to kiss” award, it’d go to Baldur’s Gate 3. And while I really don’t want to put words in their mouth, I think the sentiment rings true for all two of us named Andrea at Destructoid. Contributor of excessively good takes, Andrea Gonzalez, wrote about how BG3 is a delightful dating sim. Andrea Shearon approves.

Okay, okay — outside of all the love-dovey stuff, BG3 is the incredible culmination of a CRPG that spent years in early access, with developer Larian Studios tweaking the formula with fan feedback along the way and delivering this massive, choice-driven adventure. It’s also one I refuse to play on a console, so here we are.

Dave the Diver

I’ve always heard it’s pretty damn hard to find success as a restaurateur, and Dave’s experience here says as much. Developer Mintorocket’s adventure RPG drops the pro Scuba diver into a cheeky journey with his friends opening a sushi business. At night, you’ll deal with the restaurant. In the day, you’ll fight underwater creatures like a half-crab, half-tractor (?) abomination.

It’s all to keep the business going. The juggle between grinding for fish and managing the sushi spot was one Destructoid contributor Christine Choi adored. In her review, Christine mentions how she “can’t put it down” as Dave the Diver aces the balance between gameplay styles and delivers something lighthearted, engaging, and easy to take at your own pace.

What’s next on Destructoid’s GOTY schedule

We’re reaching the halfway point as Destructoid’s nominee announcements draw to a close. Next week, on December 18, check in again as we reveal this year’s winners.

Andrea Shearon

Associate Editor – Andrea is Destructoid’s own little FFXIV encyclopedia with her hands in a bit of everything. She’s been in the games industry for almost seven years, and has a fondness for RPGs, MMOs, farming sims, survival games, and the occasional horror adventure.

More Stories by Andrea Shearon